Fresh Pizza
Thin-crust pizzas made to order with signature sweet sauce and quality toppings.
- Available well-done for extra crispiness
- Hot slices ready for quick pickup
- Full size pizzas for families and groups
At a Glance
Sweet Tomatoes stands out as South Yarmouth's go-to pizza destination, famous for their thin-crust pies with distinctive sweet sauce that keeps families coming back year after year. Customers consistently praise the fresh-made pizzas, quick service, and diverse menu that caters to both locals and Cape Cod vacationers. The restaurant combines authentic Italian-American flavors with Cape Cod hospitality, making it a must-visit first stop for many families arriving on the Cape.
- Famous sweet pizza sauce
- Fresh-made thin crust
- Quick service
- Welcoming local atmosphere
Why Customers Choose SWEET TOMATOES
Based on 500 customer reviews
- Signature sweet sauce recipe not found elsewhere on Cape
- Thin-crust pizza made fresh daily, available well-done for extra crispiness
- Hot slices ready for immediate takeout when you're in a hurry
- Extensive menu beyond pizza including wings, wraps, and grinders
- Local Cape Cod decor creates authentic neighborhood atmosphere
- Consistent quality that makes families return year after year
Location & Local Context
Address: 461 Station Ave, South Yarmouth, MA 02664, USA
Phone: (508) 394-6054
Hours: Friday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Monday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Sunday 12:00 – 8:00 PM, Tuesday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Thursday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Wednesday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Parking: Free parking lot available in front of restaurant
Peak times: Friday-Saturday 6pm-8pm, Sunday 2pm-6pm
Nearby neighborhoods: South Yarmouth, West Yarmouth, Bass River
Nearby landmarks: Near Route 28 corridor, Close to Bass River Beach, 5 minutes from Cape Cod Inflatable Park
Services & Offerings
Wings & Appetizers
Buffalo wings and tasty appetizers perfect for sharing or as a meal starter.
- Buffalo wings with quick preparation
- Various appetizer options
- Great for takeout or dine-in
Wraps & Grinders
Fresh wraps including Caesar wraps and hearty grinders like their popular meatball sub.
- Caesar wraps made fresh
- Meatball grinders are customer favorites
- Perfect for lunch or lighter dinner
Dine-In Experience
Cozy restaurant seating with charming Cape Cod decor for those who prefer to stay and enjoy.
- Local Cape-themed atmosphere
- Family-friendly seating
- Full menu available for dine-in
Customer Reviews
⭐ 4.5 out of 5
500 total reviews
Most Frequently Mentioned
- Pizza quality (89 mentions)
- Quick service (67 mentions)
- Sweet sauce (54 mentions)
- Friendly staff (43 mentions)
Rating has remained steady at 4.5 stars over the past year. 18 new reviews this month.
★★★★★
“5 stars for the super cool dudes who serve pretty tasty food. The pizza is really good and they have some tasty treats too. It's best for take out but there are seats for eat in.”
— Ann P★★★★★
“Came here for Caesar Wrap and Buffalo wings. Was not disappointed. The service was quick and the price was reasonable. I loved the decor around the restaurant.”
— Chris Kolacz★★★★★
“For the last 3 years, my family’s first stop on the Cape has been Sweet Tomatoes! There is something for everyone but the pizza cannot be beat. Thin crust, sweet sauce, and always made fresh. If you don’t have time to wait, they have slices available. Definitely recommend checking out if you’re looking for pizza on the cape!”
— Michaela D.★★★★★
“I live down the street and have tried 80% of the menu. Pizzas are great, I always ask for them well done to get them crispy. Don't sleep on their meatball grinder either! Unfortunately they recently took off my favorite menu item, a cheeseburger pizza inspired by a Big Mac. I hope they bring it back!”
— D BFrequently Asked Questions
Yes, we keep hot slices available for immediate pickup, perfect when you don't have time to wait for a fresh pizza.
Absolutely! Just ask for your pizza 'well done' and we'll make it extra crispy - it's a popular request from our regulars.
Our signature sweet sauce recipe sets us apart from other pizza places and is what keeps customers coming back year after year.
We offer both takeout and dine-in service with cozy seating, though many customers prefer takeout for convenience.
Yes, we have convenient parking available right outside the restaurant for both quick pickup and dine-in customers.
Business Activity
Status: Open now
Peak hours: Weekend evenings 6-8pm
Fresh pizza: Made throughout the day
Popular this month: Pepperoni pizza, Buffalo wings, Caesar wraps
Similar Businesses Nearby
Pelham House Resort
⭐ 4.4 (709) · 4.5 miles
14 Sea Street, Dennis Port
Old Yarmouth Inn
⭐ 4.6 (894) · 2.3 miles
223 Massachusetts 6A, Yarmouth Port
Yarmouth House
⭐ 4.4 (2049) · 3.1 miles
335 Massachusetts 28, West Yarmouth
The Ocean House Restaurant
⭐ 4.5 (904) · 4.8 miles
425 Old Wharf Road, Dennis Port
Subway
⭐ 3.9 (145) · 0.3 miles
12 Whites Path, South Yarmouth
Inaho Japanese Restaurant
⭐ 4.7 (368) · 2.5 miles
157 Massachusetts 6A, Yarmouth Port
People Also Search For
- pizza South Yarmouth MA
- thin crust pizza Cape Cod
- family restaurants Yarmouth MA
- takeout pizza near me
0/100
Online Visibility Score: Excellent
How easily local customers can find and choose this business online.
Reviews & Reputation35/35
Online Presence33/33
Business Completeness17/17
Engagement5/15
This business profile is managed with Buzza AI on Clover.
Powered by Buzza AI on Clover
SWEET TOMATOES manages this profile with Buzza AI on Clover. Business owner? Manage your listing from your Clover Dashboard.